GoldMoney Alert - 22 May 2008

Silver Price Manipulation

The following report is by David Morgan, proprietor of Silver Investor and someone who I consider to be one of the top experts on silver.

David makes several key points, but the important and overriding one to me is his observation that the paper market in silver dwarfs the physical market. View the differences between paper and physical to be like the child's game, musical chairs. When the music stops, there are not enough chairs for everyone, or as David estimates, there is only one chair for every hundred people. The implications are obvious.

Those who hold paper are in a decidedly different position than people already sitting on chairs by holding physical silver. So what would you rather own? Physical silver or just some paper representation of silver?

Lastly, there are only two ways to own physical silver. Buy it and store it yourself, or buy it and ask someone to store it for you, which is what we do in GoldMoney. There are no other alternatives.

Silver Price Manipulation

David Morgan

This week I must address the latest Commodity and Futures Trading Commission (CTFC) findings that, "The U.S. commodities regulatory body found no evidence that silver prices had been manipulated downward by short sellers after re-examining long-term and recent allegations of misconduct."

I was asked by Dow Jones to comment on the CFTC findings. The first point I stated was: "It is not possible to manipulate the trend in a market, but it is possible to 'manage' the price within silver's uptrend." I went on to state that the price of silver can be managed, within certain boundaries, through short selling. I believe silver would be far higher if not for selling of vast amounts of silver that doesn't exist, or "naked shorts."

Now some I know well in the industry build a case that all or almost all of the silver sold short on the exchange is not sold naked but indeed is true hedging, primarily by base metals mining companies. This at the surface level may appear to be correct, until it is realized that almost all of the real physical silver that is delivered to end users (primarily to industrial consumers) is accomplished by means of over-the-counter (OTC) contracts known as "forwards." This is not accomplished in the futures market!

My point is simple: If the true sale of physical silver is done in an unregulated market based upon private contracts, then what is the purpose of the futures market? Why did the London Bullion Management Association trade nearly 30 billion ounces of silver last year? Why did the futures and options exchanges trade almost 60 billion ounces of silver last year?

Let's get a bit real here. If the total silver supply is roughly one billion ounces and we can measure NINETY times that amount being "traded" on the reporting exchanges, does it not beg the question why?

Further remember, there is a whole vast amount of silver "trading" going on in the OTC market that does not report at all. It could easily be as large as the reporting exchanges.

Let's be conservative here and state only 10 billion ounces of silver is dealt in the OTC market. So when I state naked sales and can prove perhaps ONE HUNDRED TIMES the amount of silver exists on paper than exists in the physical world, you must question the logic of "hedging." The derivatives markets are alive and well in both silver and gold, and there is roughly one hundred ounces "claimed" on paper for every physical ounce of silver.

So, ask a very basic question: How is the price of silver set? As if there is less than half a billion ounces of physical silver? Or is the price acting as if there is a hundred times as much silver? For those who don't know, this is a rhetorical question! Think fractional reserve banking system, which keeps about one percent of the total in reserve, because what depositor is going to cash in on their demand deposits? One percent is what the bank needs to keep the present day scheme going. In the case of banking, more "money" can be created by a computer keystroke. But real silver, well...that will pose a problem.

Another question that has always bothered me is, Why does the CFTC set a limit of 7.5 million ounces of silver as the most that can be taken off the exchange in a given delivery month? If you look back and see the Comex inventory level change when Warren Buffett made his purchase, you will notice a huge off take of physical silver from the Comex. This cannot happen again; the rules state there is a limit on the amount of physical silver that can be taken off the exchange.

So, for the umpteenth time, I will answer the following question: "Why doesn't some big investor come along and just buy up the remaining silver?" Answer: It cannot be done. There are delivery limits now! Let me repeat!! It cannot be done, there are delivery limits NOW!!

Oh, you might ask, "Is there any limit to the amount of silver that can be sold on paper?" Well, the main purpose of this missive is to prove that there is no limit to the amount of paper silver that can be created!

DAVID MORGAN, the founder of the Silver Investor, has studied the silver market for over thirty years. To learn more about Mr. Morgan and to become a subscriber to his free newsletter, click here: http://www.silver-investor.com/

Published by GoldMoney
Edited by James Turk

This material is prepared for general circulation and may not have regard to the particular circumstances or needs of any specific person who reads it. The information contained in this report has been compiled from sources believed to be reliable, but no representations or warranty, express or implied, is made by GoldMoney, its affiliates, representatives or any other person as to its accuracy, completeness or correctness. All opinions and estimates contained in this report reflect the writer's judgement as of the date of this report, are subject to change without notice and are provided in good faith but without legal responsibility. To the full extent permitted by law neither GoldMoney nor any of its affiliates, representatives, nor any other person, accepts any liability whatsoever for any direct, indirect or consequential loss arising from any use of this report or the information contained herein. This report may not be reproduced, distributed or published without the prior consent of GoldMoney.